12.30.07
Update on Recent Copyright Brouhaha
The person who originally reported about the copyright lawsuit in California has sent an update. Apparently, she is not a member of the guild in question.
Joanne writes:
Though I received the story directly from a member, it was I who concluded the problem came from an individual block. Since then I have read their archived newsletters and knowing the name of the plaintiff also viewed her website, I have concluded that the problem probably arose from the use of her quilting designs and then in an added layer of error the guild decided to sell patterns. They likely received permission to use the quilting designs but overstepped the permission when they wanted to sell the patterns. I have no proof of these conclusions, but that is likely why the quilt had to be withdrawn from any public viewing - it had overall Sashiko quilting.
My reaction to this note is one of surprise. I also wonder what is so special about any particular Sashiko quilting stitches. There are many traditional Japanese Sashiko stitching patterns, so why would these stitch units have been so unique that the quilt had to be confiscated?
I can see that this situation is probably more complicated than I had first thought.
As of just a few minutes ago, when I checked my e-mail, I had received no statement or answers to my questions from the plaintiff.
The only way any of us will “win,” in this situation, is if all the facts are put on the table so that quilters can learn vicariously from the mistake(s) surrounding what happened. It is unfortunate that this information was presented by the letter writer, before all the facts were known.
Joanne’s intention seems to have been to warn quilters to be aware that they do not infringe on the rights of copyright holders. She was using this lawsuit as an example of what can happen. I still would appreciate knowing the particulars from those “in the know.” If quilters can’t understand exactly what was done that is questionable, the lawsuit was an exercise in futility that simply appears odious and insufferable to those “not in the know.” Not understanding the problem may result in future, similar issues.
So, here we wait. I am ready and willing to correct the record at any time, and I always stand on the side of truth and justice. Your comments are always welcome.
Patricia Cummings
